Showing posts with label Godel. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Godel. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 31, 2015

Dead Souls



By Nikilai Gogal
I picked up this book because I understand that it is highly recommended by Putin.  It’s not that I am a Putin fan, but rather I wanted to understand the personality of Russia’s leader.  Apparently Dead Souls could be considered a Russian classic of the 19th Century.  The work itself is actually incomplete and therefore needs an introduction to explain how a reader should grapple with incompleteness.  Later works by Gogal, separate from the book, present different endings.  In reality the original seems to draw a conclusion sufficient to claim an ending and so you have to wonder why the drama around incompleteness.  Ironically a German mathematician named Kurt Godel explored and wrote a theorem that nothing is complete.   And tragically ironic, few people know of Godel’s work and  so they possess the anxiety of leaving any work undone.  I do muse at the similarity of the names born in succeeding centuries.  The best I can conclude on this question is that the various endings would change the moral message of an otherwise bland though bizarre adventure through rural Russian villages of the mid 1800’s. Thus society is unnecessarily and therefore ironically appeased.

The story line begins with a middle aged member of the gentry class, Pavel Ivanovich Chichikov, venturing through rural Russia with two serfs to manage the carriage and his belongings.  The scene setting is soaked in color and humor.  The reader cannot avoid appreciating the manor of dress that each character would wear.   AT books end one couldn’t help but go out and purchase a ‘frock coat’.   It’s as though color of scene helped the author make humorous quips about the character conflict with himself in the mirror and the interplay with other characters.  Irony places the book on par with Greek Tragedy.  So in that a theme of bizarre quest becomes the center of discussion for the author who tells the story in third person. 

Chichikov is a charismatic man who rides in his carriage into any town and instantly charms the people he meats.  Well aware of his skill to charm, Chichikov targets first city officials and then land owners.  If you owned a serf, you were a target.  The reader, becomes familiar with the cultural landscape of 19th century Russia in terms of how towns a seem to thrive at the will of one land owner of upper aristocratic class of men with title, through the gentry to the, peasants and then serfs.  Chechikov’s quest is to purchase Dead Souls.  So this idea on its own is bizarre.  As the story unfolds understanding what exactly a dead soul is and where its usefulness only makes things slightly less bizarre.  Or you might look at it as bizarre from a bureaucratic perspective.

Amidst this drama, the reader first becomes attuned to Chichikov’s scheme.  His targeting methods include charm. His negotiating methods were brutal.  He would know by title those that would own serfs and so they are primary targets.  However, he is no stranger to pursue word-of-mouth references of which he wastes no time going from one home to another. He negotiates first as though he is helping out a lifelong friend, of whom he just met.  The conversation is logical until the target seller asks difficult questions.  As the layers of questions stack up, Chichikov will finally find himself red in the face demanding  the conveyance of deeds to souls of serfs who have died. 
Over time the town folks evolve from  first a unanimous opinion that this new-comer to town is to be revered as a person of nobility to a person of scandalous corruption.  The gossip begins with the women who then convince their husbands, who then convince each other that something must be done.  This is all done in a tornado of gossip that springs to a climax while Chichikov is nursing a cold.  By the time he is recuperated enough to come out on the town he learns he is being brought to trial.  His only saving grace is the town folks catch themselves being caught up in the folly of escalating gossip and nothing of fact to convict Chichikov.

None the less Chichikov realizes it’s time to move on as he has exacted all he can from the town.  In his ride to the next town, the author takes time to circle back on Chichikov’s past where the reader learns what formulated Chichikov’s motives and methods.  He was a man made by Russia and his methods were formulated by the bureaucracy of Royal Russia.  Ironically as history has it the 20th century Communist  Russia changed nothing to improve the life of a rural Russian.  So far in to the 21st century, it would be public opinion that corrupt bureaucracy is still at the core of Russian society.  And it seems they embrace it as a part of their heritage.   I would suggest that Putin as well as most Russian are charmed by the book because they have lifelong first and experience with a society that does not hold justice out as a centerpiece of their core values.  They are who they are.  Not being Russian I could be their accuser and public defender at the same time and say there is a sense of justice stemming from their Christian values, however it is covered with a heavy blanket of civil corruption.

Saturday, February 4, 2012

Eugine Onegin

Eugine Onegin
By Douglas Hofstadter

Hofstadter’s preface is an intriguing love story by a master of symbols and patterns who falls prey to compulsiveness and pounces on random coincidences. He gives in to love-for the poem, if only for the love of his wife, Carol. The question that anyone familiar with Hofstadter is; is this book Carol’s symbol, his deceased wife living beyond her mortality? Ironically, the story line by the original author Sergeevich Pushkin, the godfather of Russian literature, is a love story as well. Hence you’ll find two parallel themes in my review. First is the answer to the Hofstadter question. The second is a question to all of you. Pushkin’s love story told in poetry is one of familiar refrain. I suspect love manifests itself in many ways and thrives on many different levels..

In Hofstadter’s book I Am a Strange Loop, discussed in my review found here on Cigar Room of Books, he tells a touching true-life story of his wife’s passing. In that story he eventually climbs out of the funk he found himself in. This translation project was his bridge. He provides a rationale of how the entwined life between himself and Carol became an entwined thought pattern. Thought being capable of transcending modalities, allows his wife Carol to live on through the people she was close to, and then through generations. In piecing together the story in Strange Loop and his preface in this book, I have come to conclude that the hidden power of love drove Hofstadter, to this project so that he could release his grief and find a higher plane to express his love for Carol. The most remarkable feat I find is this book is Hofstadter's soul, already fluent in a few languages which are mere symbols of thought, flowing from the patterns of DNA, he translates a poem written in Russian, a language he is not fluent in, by the most renowned Russian author ever, and receives high accolades from Russians who say he captured the pure essence of Pushkin’s heart and mind.

You find evidence in chapter 7 verse 23: to my summation. This stanza is Tatyana’s soul reacting to the same books her long departed Onegin had read. The story places Tatyana in the same study that Onegin had spent time in. Pushkin infers that time and space becomes only somewhat relevant as she is experiencing the thoughts and feelings of her denied true love through the common denominator of the word symbols. In that room she becomes one with her lover. All of the entwined expressions of life between Douglas and Carol continue through their children and through their work.

There could be found on many pages,
The clench marks of his fingernails.
The girl, her gaze alert, engages
Two eager eyes upon these trails
Tatyana notes, with trepidation
The types of thought and observation
That struck Onegin forcefully
Things he agreed with silently.
The margins brought to her attention
Tracks from his pencil, trapped in coal.
Thus everywhere Onegins soul
Transduced itself, without intention
Through jotted words, through checks and hooks,
Through interrogatory crooks.

The story line is pretty simple and one that should find common experience amongst most readers. What makes this book worth reading is the story is told in verse. I am told many a Russian has it committed to memory which is a testament to the passion I have experienced in my Russian experiences. Eugene is your classic Russian youth full of vim and vigor and a penchant to be a man of the world. Tatyana is a unique young woman with a penchant to marry the person she loves rather than the person presented to her by society’s fate. As the story unfolds Tatyana submits her soul to Onegin in classic Russian form through a love letter invitation. Onegin, who inwardly discovers her inward beauty as well as his love for her rebukes Tatyana as being too vulnerable to withstand the realities his antics. As tradition forces herself, Tatyana is destined to be matched up with someone in the person of Eugene’s rival friend. The rivalry ends in a duel where Eugene while victor, he is deeply remorseful and becomes reclusive. As there lives take separate courses Eugene eventually finds in his approach to Tatyana the “shoe on the other foot” and an already married Tatyana, still with a deep love for Eugene must now reproach him.

To comment on the story and its translation I provide the following view. In my youth the popular song was Love The One You’re With and we all did. But until a man seasons a few years he is lacking in the skills and judgment to respond appropriately. There is much more to love than the outward directed world reveals. My guess is that the reason Russians can remember the poem, is it sings a familiar refrain in the lives of many. In reading this book if you find the same fate, close your eyes and be there now. In this world where you come in to it and leave it alone, and some times in the middle you feel the same; this poem committed to memory, may be your one friend to help you feel not so alone. I wonder if Hofstadter found this same experience?

From a scientific or Darwinian view and a take away on Hofstadter: If DNA is a pattern that evolves through experiences within each host, it is the pattern or symbol of your soul that lives on. Hence life that looks to flourish and continue on in this world requires a host willing to conceive, bare and nourish the symbol of her being, a child. That requires a mate. In natural mate selection to the host searches for a mate with the mutual respect for life, found in love for one another. A love for one another that are vested in the ability to recognize the interconnectedness found in oneness of mankind beginning with one’s self. This couple then forms a life together contributing to a home, village, and state world. This is where the continuation of their DNA (symbols of their souls) continues on.

Sunday, December 12, 2010

The Secret History of Freemasonry

The Secret History of Freemasonry
by Paul Naubon

This book is a paradigm shifter. A game changer. For all those teaching the mind-set of the Dark Ages I say tisk-tisk. Middle...Yes. Dark...No. Paul Naubon while enlightening the reader with a brilliant unfurling of the lineage of Freemasonry back to the coagulation of society of man from hunter gatherer to agrarian age to the industrial world, the original domino is not lost from view. In fact it gains in its energy, and with that immense sense of energy the reader is able to realize that behind the mystery of intrigue, there is a bit of truth to the simple act of connecting with the earth, the universe and being one with God.

The first domino begins with the rational for builders/masons to become a revered person in a new society where people actually pool their resources together and organize the harvest of their crops. It is then that builders became essential in building first houses, then utility buildings. An ancient mason looked at his work as he visualized the earth’s resources and transforming them into to a statement of mans existence. Hence one’s home became a spiritual place. As man began to meet with others in general assembly, the notion of Temples became a pinnacle of his work. Before he struck each rock to transform earth into a statement of himself and his extended society, he made a spiritual testament as to his purpose. While this gave meaning to his work he began to realize that this is special work that required codification, rituals, and a sense of a threshold to cross in order to enter into the practice. And hence my dear reader I introduce to you the worlds first college and trade union all in one felled swoop.

So with that introduction Naubon spends an appropriate amount of time on the history of architecture in a Western Civilization setting that clearly includes the Orient. This with extensive Muslim influence, twin to that of Byzantine world is work of the Benedictines of Cluny which really was exported to Constantinople from France, witnessed by the Basilicas built in the East, and then back to the West. The Templars became the bridge and guard as they most certainly gained their earliest knowledge of architecture, by virtue of proximity to the Masons themselves, and consequently its trade secrets, from the Benedictines and Cistercians. Secrets that were Christian in origin, influenced by Muslim minds and exported back to the Christian West. So while in the East, Persia to be more precise, The Templars benefited from Islam where they opened numerous doors for Christians toward social understanding and harmony. On the Muslim side, the principle artisans of is action were the Isaimli sects, particularly Karmates and the Assassins; all Persian, descendants of Zoroastrians and therefore Sunni converts who evolved into Shiite to find a way to accept the hostile rule of the Sunni. One has to wonder what happened to the peaceful Persians that we now refer to as Iranian? Was it 1,000 years of Islam? Or was it 1,000 years of Sunni’s influence, and then 80 years of Christan Western quasi colonization attempts? These questions do not get a any attention, raised or answered by the author. But what is clear is what the Templars adopted through their Mason builders was as a willingness for coexistence of peace with all men, something I find rare in Arab history with exception to Saladin, and ironically enough something that King Phillip of France took objection to.

Pulling the thread through time, the reader learns in order to build their church on Fleet Street, the Templars had to import an architectural brotherhood from the Holy Land and thus may well have been responsible for the formation of the original masons guild in London. To see Masons evolve to Freemasons within the covers of this book derives much more intrigue to the well founded speculation that our founding fathers of the United States were one and the same. Could it be that power still has its roots in heritage well beyond the dynasty of any King’s family? The question does not get answered, nor is it even stated or implied, but is merely the wild speculation of a novice student reader of the subject, me.

Where did this thread of power come from is answered early on in the book where one learns that the first trade union, the first college, and the first brotherhood; all speaking about the same group of men, were masons? They adopted a code of conduct, rituals and rites. Because the clergy of the church, Jewish Muslim and the royalty were equally dependent on this skill to convert the wondrous works of The Mason's minds in to the wondrous works of architecture. In making a statement of their civilization they were granted special privileges in society and as well were excused from certain civilian obligations including taxes. Early on the Church brought along all the royalties of the Holy Roman Empire and all of the Celtic Royalty to to the practice of embracing the strong arm of the Templar’s. These Templars were the protectors of the Masons which gave fertile ground for their power, not only be wielded by the sword, but through the political web and flow of commerce that came with their sheltering of the masons builders guild. Albeit this is only implied by the author; this reader took the bait to deep water.

The Templar’s actually ruled most of Paris among other cities through Masonic Order influence, which is thoroughly described in the book, a case is made for Phillip to wrest back that control through contrived cooperation with Pope Clement. So the reason for the condemnation of the Templars is not to be sought in a heretical deviation. In fact they were never condemned by the Pope – who was satisfied with simply dissolving the Order – but by temporal authority. The dissolution was forth coming from Rome in payment of a debt of gratitude owed the King of France. Be warned this drama is clearly not the main story line of the book, and only gets a couple of paragraphs. What does come out is that of the architecture and culture within “commanderis” as they were called under Templar control shaped early Paris and still has its say in the 21 century. That say is the "mind of the Middle Ages". With this in mind a tour of today’s Paris becomes that much more intriguing to a studied eye. In the course of this enlightenment, the reader cannot help at this juncture of the book to say the Dark Ages were much more enlightening than many modern scholars portray to their students. I believe it was that spiritual enlightenment that gave America’s founding fathers the courage and power to give rebirth to an ideology that King Phillip suppressed for a mere 400 years.

At the core of Masonry and its off shoot Freemasonry is found the ideology to treat all mankind as one. It is very much in keeping with the doctrine of Jesus Christ, and yet preceded him by a couple thousand years. Ironically Christ was a carpenter, Muhammed was a merchant. The signatories (of the members of builders trades, Freemasons) went on to list the two guiding principles for all the brothers activities” Love and cherish all men as if they were your brothers and kin; render to Ceaser that which is Ceasers’s and render unto God that which is God’s. Hence we pledge allegiance to the flag one nation (of many) under God. Its an idea of the masons that we are all one with the universe of the earth all animate and inanimate objects, and they were the first to make a science in molding that universe to suit an improved standard of living.

At the core of the code is the following that I took verbatim from the mind of Naubon through his well researched book. Call the rest of my review a distortion, but please as a reader of my work take the following to heart. With that came a code of ethics, found in the American Declaration of Independence, Constitution, and Bill of Rights. The code is very much Christian based as it follows the natural laws of the universe. But more so Masonic ideology is God based to include that of any faith and many trades and orders of business. I cannot improve on Naubon so I will close with his words:

Those who have faith in God don’t see him with the eyes of children, enthroned on top of a mountain of sugar between blessed rivers of honey. We refrain from talking of him too much and seeking to define him. It is preferable to envision the itinerary that allows us to approach him and to think that God constructed himself in such a way that man’s gravitation to the Spirit is, by virtue of reason, the best proof of God’s existence. This increasing number who do not believe in God or who turn him into an abstraction out of concern for tolerance, base what they deem to be just, good, and desirable on the good use of reason, on their own intelligence, and on the infinite perfectibility of humanity.

The difference between these two attitudes is essentially dependent on the value given to the origin of reason: God, still unknown to the believer; or unknown, for the nonbeliever another cause for natural laws that govern life. In one case or the other, if we use our ability to reason as best we can, to work with the certitude of the goal yet to be attained, what are we doing if not working under the auspices of and for the glory of this Unknown? And what better symbol for this Unknown than that of the Great Architect of the Universe?


Page 23: It is also worth noting that thin influence of these associations occurred in an era contemporary with that of Charles Martel, who, as legends in France and England have it and we shall see, played a prominent role in the formation of Freemasonry.

NOTES:

Page 25: Before studying the fate and evolution of their collegia, that continued to exist in those parts of Italy that remained free, as well as the collegia in Eastern Empire,, we need to look as to them in the Lombard Kingdom. This region has left behind the memory of renowned architects.

Page 33: Finally there is one important fact produced its own ramifications: The still thriving Byzantine collegia, with their traditions, rites, and symbols, were later discovered by the Arabs and the Crusaders, a discovery that both turned to their own advantage.

Page 34: at the time of the formation of Ecclesiastical formations in the Gothic regions, the Church did not merely represent a belief and form of worship, it also constituted a political organization.

Page 35: in 300 - 600 As a self contained body, the Church had retained its own rights. It remained subject to Roman laws. At this time, the Church did not merely represent a belief and a form of worship; it also constituted a political organization. As a veritable State, it exercised all the attributes of one and extended it authority over all Christian countries.

The builders from the collegia, who, as we have seen, found refuge with bishops, discovered themselves to be bound simply by close personal ties to these prelates. This was not the case for members of the collegia who were integrated into the monasteries. While their former status had vanished, they were better able to survive corporative preserving their practices and traditions and even their rites and secrets which allowed them to form veritable schools whose influence often radiated quite far.

Page 39: The Benedictine Order to which Romanesque art owes the greatest debt is definitely that of Cluny. During the twelfth century the abbey of Cluny was the center and regulator of civilization.

Page 61: in order to build their church on Fleet Street, the Templars had to import an architectural brotherhood from the Holy Land and thus may well have been responsible for the formation of the original masons guild in London.

Page 66: The Templars most certainly gained their earliest knowledge of architecture, and consequently its trade secrets, from the Benedictines and Cistercians. In fact, we have already pointed out the Romanesque Cistercian style of the basilicas built by the Crusaders in the East.

Page 67: In addition to their servant brothers, the Templars also employed Christian workers who were not officially members of the Order. These persons were sometimes Crusaders, but might also be local operatives especially in northern Syria, where the Armenian and Syrian population had remained entirely Christian and welcomed the Crusaders as liberators.
Huges Plagon, the second continuer of Guillame de Tyr, writes that in 1253 the Saracens of Damascus came to Acre, destroyed Doc and Ricordane and captured Sidon, “and slew eight hundred men and more and took prisoners, including masons as well as other folks, some four hundred persons.” This quote from a contemporary underscores the regard held for the masons on the part of the Crusaders.

Page 69: Legist of the time not only considered Roman Law as the science and law of the past. They endeavored, with deep faith, to bring these laws back to life, to restore them to common practice in both institutional and private arenas. In France, especially, government and administrative personnel were soon recruited primarily from among these legist. The evolution reached full flowering under Phillip the Fair, when French legist strove to formulate the power of the Roman emperor for the kings’s benefit.

Page 71: On the Christian side the Templars were always the most active artisans of these kinds of alliances. In 1129, the Templar grand master urged Baldwin II to come to an understanding with the Ismaili Abu Fewa. Under terms of their agreement, Baldwin exchanged Tyre for Damascus. In fact, “for some eighty years, the Templars maintained close relations with the heads of the Isamaili sect. Similarly, in 1136 the Templars of Saint John of Acre became friends with Turkish captain Unur.

Page 73: Islam opened for Christians numerous doors toward social understanding and harmony. On the Muslim side, the principle artisans of this action were the Isaimli sects, particularly Karmates and the Assassins

In the social sphere, Karmatism is characterized by the organization of labor and groups of workers into professional corporations which seem to have been in existence since the tenth century and were connected with religious brotherhoods. It is important to note the contemporary recollections of asnafs and turuq in Shiite sects emphasized both spiritually and socially education value and labor.
The Karmati movement, which is the source of these Muslim institutions, stands out both religiously and philosophically in its introduction to Islam of basic foreign assumptions – primarily those that were Hellenic, Neopaltonic, and pseudo Hermatic, and “Sabine”.

Page 75: It is this extensive Arab influence, twin to that of Byzantine world (the work of the Benidictines of Cluny), that prompted the first cultural and philosophical renaissance that took place in the West during the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, especially France.

Page 78: Going beyond simple architectural instruction, the influence of the Ismailians and the Assassins also left a mark on Templar ceremonies as well as other of their customs. “Ismailism clearly seems to have been a practical model that the Templars adopted almost immediately .

It is also acceptable to believe that outside the respective dogmas of Assassins and Templars there were flexible interpretations of ideas and doctrines. … It becomes all more likely given that the faith of Eastern Christians showed such distinctive features that it was almost impossible to discern any demarcations between Christian sects and the derivatives of Islam. Both sides came closer to one shared ideal. The Fatimids of Cairo imagined the possibility of peace universalism that was the rebirth of the thought of the pharaoh Amenhotep IV.

Page 79: So the reason for the condemnation of the Templars is not to be sought in a heretical deviation. In fact they were never condemned by the pope – who was satisfied with simply dissolving the Order – but by temporal authority. … The dissolution was forth coming from Rome in payment of a debt of gratitude owed the king of France

Page80: In short, it is acceptable that the destruction of the Order was legitimized by reasons of stats; it was only the means used to accomplish this destruction that were iniquitous.

Page 90 : The religious order that appears most prominently at the origin of the franc métiers is that of Templars, a fact that has largely gone un noticed. In the jurisdiction of its commanderies, free craft was the rule, just as the bourgeois residents of Templar-controlled areas were free bourgeois. In the cities where the Templars had establishments, a distinction can be made in the same craft between franc craftsman living in the Templar domain, and artists who were merely free who worked in other quarters and were subject to royal an manorial charges and taxes as well as to their own trade regulations.

Page 91: The exemptions and privileges that craftsmen benefited from in Templar commanderies were particularly propitious for increasing the Orders’s influence and popularity. In the troubled times of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, when the craftsmen and bourgeois of the cities sought protection for themselves and their properties by free themselves from their cities’ control, the Temple offered them not only asylum but also the model of a free professional trade organization.

Page 101: 1.) the Templars formed monastic builders associations that possessed Greco-Roman traditions passed down by the Benedictines and Cistercians. 2.) The Templars had close ties to Christian and Muslim architectonic associations in the East and were subject to their operative and initiatory influences. 3.) In Europe the Templars were the source of the creation and development of builders associations that long enjoyed specific exemptions. The terms franc métiers and free masonry are derived from these associations. 4.) Following the dissolution of the Templar Order, a certain number of Templars were incorporated into the mastery associations.

Page 108: In Paris the Templars’ quarter, which was in full development at this time, must have been particularly appealing to them. “Because of the great hurt and great rapines they suffered in the provost-ship,” writes Joinville, “the little people dared no longer to remain on the grounds of the king, but sought instead to dwell in other provost-ships and manorial holdings; and thus it was lands of the king that became so sparse that when he held his plebiscite, no more than tem or twelve people would elect to attend
Craftsmen were all the more inspired to dwell in the Temple’s jurisdiction, for doing so, let us recall, gave those who came seeking assistance and protection the benefit of two important privileges: asylum and trade exemptions.

Page 110 Thus privileges of asylum and franchise were not common. They long made the Temple highly popular among craftsmen. It was the influx of these artisans that helped populate and enrich the Parisians establishment of the Order – so much so that is was chosen to be the Order’s headquarters when the Christians lost the Holy Land.
The Temple enclosed its population within a huge commandery, effectively a large city that manufactured everything needed to live there. The Parisian merchants, craftsman, bourgious who lived under the Temple jurisdiction were so numerous in comparison to those who were dependents of the royal provost- ship, and tutelary action of the Order was so powerful, that the Templars can be credited with the transformation of the hansa, home to the Hanseatic League of Paris, into a municipality under Saint Louis, with freedom and an administration that it helped to develop further. In support of this theory, we can note that the seat of municipal government was originall located within the Temple censive district.
My comment: and hence we detect the real reason why King Philip the Fair concocted a coup detente with a contrived story and blackmailed the pope to go along

Page 114 The Templar Order was abolished by Pope Clement V on March 22, 1312. In a bull issued on May 2 of that same year, he decreed that all Templar properties, with rights and privileges granted their owners, would be transferred to the possession of the Hospitellers of Saint John of Jerusalem. Philip the Fair ratified this transfer in France on August 24, 1212.

Page 132 The travelers of the Crusaders a Tour de France of guildsmen. Wondering the countryside echoed the rout take by those on pilgrimage, which was how they would obligatory visit Saint Baume to pay homage to Saint James, in whom they say their patron Maitre Jaques, who would have lived near Saint Magdalene and been buried in her famous cave.
They stated that their modern organization dated from the Templars and some identified Master Jacques as Jacques de Molay, the last Grand Master of the Templars.

My comment: It seems you could draw a line from these dots in history that connects our Founding Fathers, as Freemasons, to at least the origins of Christianity and possibly Christ himself.

Page 136 in a tour de Paris; To bring our stroll to an end, we cross the place de Greve and the Notre Dame bridge over the Sine. Now we are in the Cite. Here the Templars long held ownership of a large domain between Notre Dame and the palace. As we all recall, the rights of the Temple over this domain were the result of the accord concluded in 1175 by the Order and the prior of Benedictines of Saint Eloi.
Page 160 In the Purposes and Traditions of Brotherhoods; The purpose of Brotherhoods is defined as follows in an edict issued on March 1319 restoring a brotherhood of Saint James and Saint Louis that had been abolished in 1306. “to provide through one’s work the gifts of alms, to feed the indigent brothers, to have Masses sad for the living and the dead, and to busy oneself with various charitable works.” But the primary goal, not said outright here yet implied in all that was said and done was “ to elevate man to God and let him earn the Lord’s infinite grace.
We know about the organization and life of the brotherhoods thanks to eighteenth-century documents. Each trade community placed under the protection of a patron saint owned a private chapel in a church, where it held its meetings. Each had special officers who were elected to their posts-sometimes a provost and a chairman or two sworn masters would share the position.

Page 163 Of the Compagnonnages (brotherhoods, for all practical purpose); Much more than an association, it involved a state of mind, a bond and a means by which workers sharing a profession could recognize one another and thereby maintain the unity and traditions of the trade.
Page 164 But economic and social revolution soon gave the compagonnages a new purpose. More and more, the exercise of trade was becoming the privilege of masters and their sons. The journeyman could no longer move up the status to master nor buy their craft
Beaumanoir in his Costumes de Beaivais (written around 1280), considered it a serious crime to ally against the common good for the purpose of demanding a higher salary. Going on strike was punishable by prison and a fine of 60 sols.
Page 175 The signatories (of the members of builders trades, Freemasons) went on to list the two guiding principles for all the brothers activities” Love and cherish all men as if they were your brothers and kin; render to Ceaser that which is Ceasers’s and render unto God that which is God’s

Page 184 In the Organization of English Guilds; here we pause for consideration of the term free man. It is probably more effective for our purposes to use the ancient French term franc home, with connotations that we have already established: These is the franc hons who neither a serf nor a villain but has become a free bourgeois, independent of any lord Going further along these lines, we come upon the free man craftsman called a free burgess.

Page 185 In the Organization of English Guilds; As in other countries, things went differently for the professional brotherhoods that remained tied to the domain an suzerainty of the religious orders that held all rights to administer justice. This was the case in the jurisdictional areas of the Benedictine abbeys and the Templar commanderies.
My comment: this explains where Philip and Clement V fond their authority to banish the Templat Order.

Page 187 The lay mason dependent upon a guild and subsequently a ligier, lige,or vassal, could be opposed to the freemason, who is free because of his connection to the Church.
Only the Benedictines, and especially the Templars, assured trade franchises to everyone throughout the whole of their domains.
It was to the advantage of these kings to support the power and freedom of these professional associations-and it is now easier to understand the reason for the diametrically opposed policy of the French kings regarding them.

Page 191 The Cooke Manuscript dates from 1410-1420 but is a transcription of a compilation that was at least a century older. It is divided in to two parts. The first, consisting of nineteen articles, is a history of geometry and architecture. The second is a “book of duties”, including an historical introduction ; nine articles governing the organization of labor, which were allegedly promulgated at a general assembly that took place during the time of King Athelstan; nine counsels of a moral and religious nature; and four rules concerning the social life of masons. The word speculative actually appears in this document: “the son of King Athelstan was a true speculative master.” The Cooke Manuscript served as the foundation of the work of George Pyane, the second grand master of the grand lodge of London, who ensured that this organization adopted a first rule to Saint John in 1721. It also appears to have been the principal source from which Anderson drew his Book of Constitutions.

Page 206 Their religious foundation was the essential glue of all the builders groups of the Middle Ages. For the monastic brotherhoods, the propagation of the faith was the direct impulse for the construction of convents and churches. The vast brotherhoods that built the Gothic cathedrals responded to this religious inspiration. It was an era when “man looked up at the heavens with faith, in search of hope and consolation. He entrusted his misery to she who should no doubt understand it best, because she was weak and she was a woman, and she could best speak to He who could do all, because she was the Mother of God. He built the Lord of Lords; he built for Our Lady.
It is beyond doubt that religion and metaphysics were a part of the lodges’ practices, all the more so as they gave shelter to artists and scholars as well as simple craftsmen, and as the study gradually turned on a philosophy that was identical to theology.

Page 208 The hypothesis (on either side) is merely based on legend; not one historical element nor even any probability exists to accredit it. The same can also be said of similar theories suggesting that in connecting the Templars to the freemasons, the alleged heresies of one group are imputed by the other. Yes the builders associations were subject to Templar influence; this is clear. But there is no sound supporting evidence that these influences could have caused the builders, masons and carpenters to deviate from the orthodox Catholicism of that time – especially given, as we have seen that the Eastern, Muslim and Gnostic influences absorbed and transmitted by the Templars did not provide grounds enough to label them heretics.
In order to dispel any misunderstanding, it is helpful to emphasize here how the medieval mind conceives of religious orthodoxy. In the Middle Ages and up until the Reformation, though theology was the chief topic of debate, freedom of expression was quite considerable.
The apparent paradox concerning dogmas also stems from evolution-or rather change in modes of reasoning. Today’s logic finds it difficult to find a place in the framework of the dogmas and theories that medieval logic found entrance with no difficulty.

My comment: Sir Francis Bacon ushered in the change in reasoning with the dawn of modern science.
The fable that the Middle Ages were Dark Ages must be abandoned. With respect to certain crimes of intolerance, such as the Albigensian Crusade , or the condemnation of the Templars, medieval motives are much more easily explained as originating from politics rather than from any impulse to combat heresy. Heresy merely served as a pretext for seeming intolerance. True intolerance was born with the Reformation.

My comment: In this comment there is an implied indictment of the Muslim leaders of every era using religion to invoke power. The same could be applied to France, England, Germany, and Spain of the Renaissance. In modern day politics we find Muslims advocating intolerance towards Jews when really its about a hate for their supremacy in thought and entrepreneurial ism. With regard to science -v- religion it is also a fundamental struggle in politics as opposed to philosophy, when in the end the philosophy is the same study of the same universe with the same outcome.
My comment: I also find it intriguing that Martin Luther, a German brought on the dawn of true intolerance.

Page 210 It is most important to avoid viewing the audacious sculptures of the gargoyles and tympanums as merely a liberal manifestation of some satiric artists who have seen behind the scenes and grasped more than others what was really going on there. These fantasy depictions show that freedom of stone had been in practice for many centuries before freedom of the press. What was attacked were the mores of the clergy and not the religion itself.

Page 211 The international unity experienced by freemasonry was clearly displayed in the practice of the craft. The brotherhoods and communities fulfilled an educational mission insofar as each master instructed journeymen and apprentices in the craft (who transitioned across boarders, kingdom, countries).

Page 212 The Church was the sole power capable of granting and guaranteeing to builders of internationality that earned them “freedom of passage”
My comment: this was as much out of necessity of the regional power because each region did not have enough craftsmen to build their cathedral, a building that had a spiritual calling. This should not be confused with a purposeful claim to the power over the mind of the populace.

Page 213 This was why builders communities identified with monastic associations. Their ecclesiastical quality conferred upon craftsmen the privilege of inter nationality. The builders, both lay and clerical, who belonged to the Benedictine, Cistercian, and Templar brotherhoods could circulate freely, build, and settle any where in the whole of Christendom. Their freedom was guaranteed by the immunity and sovereignty of the Church to which they belonged.

More important, all craftsmen had the right to asylum and free exercise of their trade in the domains of the Templar commanderies and the popes maintained these privileged for domains held by the Knights Hospitaller or Knights of Malta until the time of the French Revolution. When we recall that the Temple numbered 900 commanderies, many of which were extensive, and 10,000 castles,, we can see how operative, especially masons who traveled widely, could be assured of finding hospitality, security, and work everywhere he went.

Mention has been made of the briefs that Popes Nicholas III in 1277 and Benoit IX in 1334 crafted with regard to mason corporations, confirming their status as a monopoly that encompassed the entire Christian world, granting them protection and an exclusive right to construct all religious edifices, and conceding to them “ the right to direct authority from only the popes” who freed them “from all local laws and statutes, royal edicts, and municipal regulations concerning conscript labor or any other obligatory imposition for all the land’s inhabitants.

My comment: you can see clearly that while Luther had a dogmatic difference to the Church of Rome/Avignon , there was a practical argument in terms of power and union busting that inspired the kings and rulers to get behind Luther’s argument. It is clearly the dogmatic argument that still prevails in the mostly Protestant prejudice over Catholics today. In intolerance that is accepted by mainstream power brokers and dealt and insensitively by the general populace (Dan Brown’s following) and received with a calloused upper lip by Catholics.

Page 214 The use of symbolism on its own constituted a universal language. Symbols were used by builders as much for spiritual teaching as for the transmission of operative craft secrets’ “During the Middle Ages,” Victor Hugo states, “the human race formed no important thought that was not set down in stone.” All form as Emile Male put it, the clothing of thought.

Page 215 The symbolism in architecture, sculpture, and staind glass, which was the work of artists under the direction of the clerics, was the expression of science and philosophy, akin to that of alchemists and Hermeticsts. Throughout the Middle Ages and the Renaissance, philosophy, metaphysics, alchemy, and Hermeticism were closely co-mingled and these disciplines were inseparable from theology.

My thoughts: With the ushering in of Sir Francis Bacons decree of science, has his original decree morphed in to a monster of politics? Was Bacon simply wrong? Did he not evolve enough to have understood that the discovery of the universe is the discovery of heaven and is the agenda of both science and religion? One comes from the perspective of substance, the other from symbols. The migration of inanimate substance to animate beings that use inanimate materials to express thought which is neither animate nor inanimate.

Page 216 It is important to underscore that the immense symbolism, the true thought of the Middle Ages, was not only the philosophical province of great doctors and scholars; it had a universal teaching power and the Church understood how to impart it to the masses. This is why there exists such perfect unity between different works – though of course the artisans who crafted it, be they ever so humble, were admirable artists .

That masons may have benefited from outside contribution to their repertoire of symbolic expression is beyond doubt. But the terrain was prepared beforehand to receive them. Traditional symbolism was a framework that was ready to accept these diverse influences. A vital force full aware of its universal nature, it did hesitate to create the synthesis and transmutation of everything it found valid in its view as debatable syncretism, or even heresy. Furthermore, during the Middle Ages everything, even that which seems most profane to us remained within the universal vision, marked by connection between the visible and the invisible. Our modern mind, habituated as much to strictly logical method of reasoning as to crystallized dogmas, often finds it difficult to perceive such mentality.


Page 217 They have grasped the hidden meaning of their writing and have understood that the symbol is a suitable kind of approach and even an expression of truth. According to the priori of the transcendent.

Page 224 It is significant that, starting at the end of the fourteenth century, all symbolism that had been used in previous centuries to formulate the Christian truths that had experienced an apotheosis in the thirteenth century gradually fell in to misuse and became incomprehensible. …After around 1530 it no longer had any deep roots. …The Cathedral no longer took the place of all the books.

Page 225 The esoteric character of the operative ritual can be boiled down to the general symbolism of the building of Solomon’s Temple, which was one of the most popular myths of the Middle Ages. This popularity reveals an interpretation of the story that reaches far beyond the tale of the magnificent temple, which David began and Solomon completed in order to provide a dignified place to worship the Eternal One and house and house the Holy of Holies, the Ark of the Covenant containing the Tablets of the Law. To the medieval mind, Solomon’s temple was the replica of God’s true temple and must be visualized on two planes: that of the Universe and the Divine Creation and that of Man the reduced form of the Universe to which Christ’s in carnation had conferred a level of grandeur or some value sequal to it The temple was a symbol of both the universal macrocosm and the human microcosm. …symbolizing the union of heaven and earth, the uncreated and the created.
Page 229 The entire Christian doctrine can be found reinforced in this text: the immanence of God in man, the realization of the law by the Incarnation of Christ, the construction within man of God’s tru temple by obedience to the Law and by Love, the symbolic figure from the Hebrew Scriptures as a sign of the gospel. This interpretation was very familiar in the Middle Ages. Developed as early as the eight century by the Venerable Bede in his work De Tempo Solomonis, it can be found everywhere in Strabo’s Ordinary Gloss of the Bible.
Page 233 Each year at Christmas or Ephany or other religious feast days and commemorative celebrations, these figures (the prophets of Israel)and their retinues paraded in costume. The precessions they formed all entered the church or cathedral and each of them, at the call of their name stepped forth to give witness to the truth, reciting verso or monologue.

My thoughts: In the middle ages the statements carved in stone was the written word. It seemed to have an immense effect on the people, not deluged with other input from the printed word, 1600s, TV 1900’s, Internet, 2000’s. Is this the reason why new churches do not have the rich artistic message of churches even in the 1800’s?

Page 234 The mason’s legend connected to Hiram belongs within the general framework. The circumstantial and fixed death of Hiram, followed by his resurrection within his own person as well as in those who emulated him, is a reflection of the Passion in the fullness of its lesson. It is also a continuation and the Christianized spiritual finality of the ancient mysteries: the attainment of immortality and the understanding through by incorporating the divine substance within ones self and through this becoming a god.

My thoughts: becoming One with God.
Page 265
“one cannot be sensibly a Deist without being Christian, and one cannot be philosophically a Christian without becoming a Catholic”…This was both awell-intentioned and laudable beginning. Still it was necessary for Freemasonry to act as the centralizing factor of Deist sentiments and the catalyst of their transcendental unity around aspiration of betterment
Page 270
The facts, however, can speak clearly enough on hteir own to require no interpretation at all. It is necessary, of course, to connect them to the social structures of the past, but only the way we think has the power to distort how we see them

Wednesday, June 30, 2010

Godel, Escher, Bach

Godel, Escher, Bach
an Eternal Golden Braid
by Douglas Hofstadter

GEB

The following are my notes as I read the book. Some day in the future I’ll ironically complete this review.

1. I read this book because I needed to understand what motivated my eldest son to pursue the study of cognitive science. If you need a different reason to inspire your to read this book, go to the book store and open GEB to pages 532- 533 and comprehend Hofstadter's "Dogmap" you would begin to appreciate the essence of the book. In this essence there is a blend of multi level constructs of thought that provides a scientific or academic understanding of cognitive science mixed in with unique blend of Hofstadter humor to clearly place this book in any philosophy college as well. . It may be just enough to lure you not just in to this book but the world of cognitive science.

2. In a self referential way, this book is about "level thinking", where knowledge at a high level may or may not have been constructed or made evident at a lower level. The notion that understanding things at a high level with the understanding of its lower level constructs is the mark of intelligence, of biological or any other means. This book examines the meaning of life if life were to begin at the thought level. In the course of discussion meaning, the scientific and then esoteric of theorems and truth come out. What is a self evident truth an undeniable proof, and what an accepted truth a bottomed out recursive analysis of any subject where bottoming out is most apropos in an every day practical world. For this reader coming to that understanding of the material put forth was a mental workout 740 pages long.

3. This Book is about
a. Meaning truth
i. evidence
b. Math – Music - Art
c. microbiology
i. how the brain works
ii. how protein works
iii. DNA, symbols
iv. RNA, the messenger
v. Thought is in the RNA message not the DNA symbols.
d. AI
i. Math
ii. symbols
iii. Logic
iv. Programming said logic

e. The Eternal Golden Braid
i. Godel’s incompleteness theorem
ii. Bach’s, Fugues and the famous Musical Offering
iii. Escher’s Tangled Hierarchy of multilevel thinking
iv. The most remarkable concept that is only implied by the author in his title at least, and can only be constructed in the context of the mind of this reader/writer, is the author’s word choice of “Eternal”, a symbol of thought that eludes to time. Eternal suggests an endless lifespan. While Hodstadter’s analytical delivery goes to the depth of constructive scientific thought, it takes on a feel of Zen Buddhism and also implies the same message of Jesus Christ that we are not of this world and that through transcendence, may you find your self at peace, one with all that is.


4. Knowing that every aspect of our physical make up is incomplete, and every aspect of every other physical manifestation of the universe is also incomplete is exactly what makes us whole in our oneness of the universe.
This is Christ's message of transcendence; your being is not of this world.

5. The book spawned TJ's DNA model of a helix reflecting symbols. Now I am envisioning a model of symbols and signals where a massive amount of laser light patterns of a mesh as in Indra's Net each of a color all rotating at different rates of speed around an axis. When the intersections of one nets mesh passes through the intersection of another net's mesh; the mixing of the individual color creates a new color. When each net is connected to a terminal bus for input that bus controls the rate of rotation. The AI comes in where when and individual net becomes so influenced by the interaction of other nets that the base color of that net changes as in changing your mind on some basic premise. The changing of color in that one mesh will now cause a change in color patterns representing a higher level of a changing of the mind. Then on a higher level each of the rotating Indra Armatures are networked. I haven't worked that out at even the idea level yet.

6. This book is like a gymnasium for the brain. Reading it is a mental workout. Your brain comes out of each workout with yet a fresher look on your world. Each degree of freshness adds a new level of thinking. Just when you think you have bottomed out Hoffstadter takes you up a level or ten and associates a presentation of a complex description of the way things work to an outward phenomena of every day occurrences that an average person can not just understand but appreciate to the extent that the mental workout will change the very way you interact with your world around. Being always conscious of your red blood cell count is not required to have a conscience understanding that a healthy diet will contribute to your red blood cell count.

7. Self referential games; without self is there meaning?

8. My thought: in a novel, why do symbols of ideas or otherwise understood as words to tell a story produce a more meaningful interaction with the reader than images, voice if a movie?

9. Page vii Hofstadter suggests a paradox that reasoning of motion as an example makes reasoning impossible.

My thoughts: if your original perspective is incongruent with reality then Hofstadter’s paradox is not a paradox at all it just faulty reasoning.

10. Page 49: isomorphism applies when two complex structures can heaped to each other I. Such a way that to each part of one structure there is a corresponding part on the other structure where corresponding means that the two parts play similar roles in there respective structures.....Information perceiving information

11. Contracrostipunctus: truth is found in the feedback loop of I. When I is a perfect mirror, forward and backwards, converse and inverse, of what is projected, no matter how multifaceted the individual, you reach the same transcendence as Jonathon Livingston Seagull’s grey to white, Gandalf's grey to white, J. S, Bach's final Contrapunctius, Christ's resurrection.

12. Meaning requires context. A DNA genome can only have a mechanical ability to grow in to it's phoneme. In the DNA of man, exists exotic propensity for the initiation of thought, a higher degree of conscience separate from consciousness. That thought only has meaning within the context of all thought, whether consciously available to the subject thinker or not. The agent of thought is the trigger responsible for the word symbol God where with standing all it's variations, derivative meanings is the context of life for mankind. Where the mystery comes in to play is the context of an environment that nourishes man without his thought. We call this nature, the nature of our context within our context. The closer we come to understanding this the more we appreciate the mechanics of nature in the study of the mystery of the universe, God..

13. Is the pursuit of AI along the lines of programming possible when programming uses logic and within logic, a derivative of the mathematical sciences, looms Godel's incompleteness theorem that states the answer lay out side the equation? In other words logic can be mapped and intelligence cannot. Intelligence is when a being can think both logically and illogically to discover or really to possibly create a new axiom. Edison thought through 15,000 experiments logically before the light came on. I am curious if the eventual success had a pre ordained logic that was proved or was there accidental discoveries along the way. Logically and illogically as said is a paradox. Is there a string of logic that contains all truths within itself? Says Godel no. So must one defy logic to find truth. Is truth separate from meaning? Can there be meaning in things that are false?

14. If in all things that are not axiomatic having a possibility of contradicting each other when is it prudent to accept a "thing" on faith and when do you take the test to the "bottom" where the shouting match occurs?

15. In TNT Hofstadter states in the context of determining truth from that which is false that it is important to follow the rules and not one's knowledge of the passive meanings of the symbols, he further states the latter type of knowledge is invaluable in guiding the route of derivation.

I interpret this invaluable route to be that of intelligence of which is the essence of breaking through mans yet to be completed understanding of the universe. To do this would be to prove Godel’s incompleteness theorem to be false. Is breaking this paradox like transcending "apparent" realities such a time?

16. In the context of bottoming out in a recursive pattern does a man’s mind have a bottom? And if so and machines are made capable to run loops adnauseum is that intelligent life? Or is that analysis paralysis? Is not a continuous loop and a bottomless recursion the same thing of which both by there definition would be very limited in determining axioms?

17. Intelligence depends crucially on the (ability to create high-level descriptions of complex arrays, such as chess boards, television screens, printed pages or paintings."

18. On recursive-ness: because we find breaking all events and object down to it's core code not only too difficult but also in many cases void of meaning anyway we break it down to appropriate levels creating symbols and each level sends signals to other symbols creating new symbols which are all abstracts of reality. Your meaning of life is at best an abstract of mine.

19. Because man freely chooses which data to hold and which to discard and which to discard abstracts are the precise results of free will. Or is it instinctive will until you are awakened to this phenomena of man over all other species. Is this not what we mean by creation...we each create our own abstract of the world around us

20. As we ramble through the arithmoqueinification logic to rationalize supernatural numbers and find Lincoln's answer to how long a man’s legs should be; you come to a demonstrable bottoming out of recursive-ness. Is there a point where deriving an axiom without proving it becomes profitable? Or in the vernacular of Hofstadter, is there a ~profit in pursuit of supernatural numbers, the pursuit of numbers that have no unique definition?

21. When a computer can see three dimensions on a flat piece of paper like humans do the discussion on artificial intelligence may begin

22. Page 521. What RNA is to life itself, agents of the DNA message to ribosome, protein, and amino acids; are people's thoughts, the message between the synapse dendrites are to each other. The balance of life rests on a scale in the context of the universe. All things must be interpreted in the context of the whole.

23. If you were to go to the book store and open GEB to pages 533- 533 and comprehend Hofstadter's "Dogmap" you would begin to appreciate the essence of the book. It may be just enough to lure you not just in to this book but the world of cognitive science.

24. Page 582. It is certain that Hofstadter is circling around the mechanics and the definition of meaning. Then by page 582 he suggests that because if the endless connections to all possibilities in a decision, time is the one variable that renders the whole definition futile. However the mechanics remain sound.

25. Page 665-8. As Hofstadter discusses his epigenesis of the crab canon and describes the fission of thought (his) he draws a parallel to bio chemistry and implies through a parallel mapping that the construct of thought and life are replicas of each other in a self refererential way

26. The reason we need a mate is we are incapable of judging whether our rough system is peculiar or not through self reference.



Bibliography

1. Page 65 things become quite confusing as soon as your perceive :meaning” in the symbols which your are manipulating.

2. Page 87 Thus, at first sight, it seems that Godel has unearthed a hitherto unknown, but deeply significant, difference between human reasoning and mechanical reasoning. The mysterious discrepancy in the power of living and non living systems is mirrored in the discrepancy between the notion of truth, and that of theorem-hood…or at least that is the romantic way to view the situation.

3. Page 133 This is the crucial fact that distinguishes recursive definitions from circular ones. There is always some part of the definition which avoids selfe reference. So that the action of constructing an object which satisfies the definition will eventually bottom out.

4. Page 142 An agnostic friend of mine once was struck by G-plot’s infinitely many infinities that he called it “ a picture of God”, which don’t think is blasphemous at all.

5. Page 162 To put it as succinctly as possible, one view says that in order for DNA to have meaning, chemical contest is necessary; the other view says that only intelligence is necessary to reveal the “intrinsic meaning” of a strand of DNA.

6. Page 192 Once again, we are up against the issue which Lewis Carrol set forth in his Dialogue: you can’t go on defending your patterns of reasoning forever. There comes a point where faith takes over.

7. Page 193 in Propositional Calculus…rules are derived. It is a part of knowledge which we have about the system. That this rule always keeps you within the space of theorem needs proofs, of course – but such a proof is not like a derivation inside the system. It is a proof in the ordinary intuitive sense – a chain of reasoning carried out in the I-mode.

8. Page 197 More radical attempts abandon completely the quest for completeness or consistency, and try to mimic human reasoning with all its inconsistencies. Such research no longer has as its goal to provide a solid underpinning for mathematics, but purely to study human thought processes.

9. Page 210 Now the translations of “6 is even” are quite different strings and it is by no means obvious that theoremhood of any one of them is tied to theoremhood of any of the others….The evidence lies in our minds, since as humans, we almost automatically think about interpretations, not structural properties of formulas.

10. Page 228 Thus, it is important to embed TNT within a wider context, a context which enables new rules of inference to be derived, so that derivations can be speeded up. This would require formalization of the language in which rules of inference are expressed-that is, the metalanguage. And one could go considerably further. However, none of those speeding up tricks would make TNT any more powerful; they would simply make it more usable.

11. Page 285 or to take a sequence of images on a television screen which shows Shirley McLean laughing. When we watch that sequence, we know that we are actually looking not at a woman, but it is the furthest thing from out min. We have these two wildly opposing representations of what is on the screen, but that does not confuse us. We can just shut one out, and pay attention to the other-which is what all of us do, Which is “more real”? It depends on whether you’re a human, a dog, a computer, or a television set.

12. Page 287 intelligence depends crucially on the ability to create high-level descriptions of complex arrays such as chessboards, television screens, printed pages.

13. Page 302 This is kind of primordial self-knowledge which is so obvious that it is hard to see it all: it is like being conscious that the air is there. We never really bother to think about what might cause these defects of our minds: namely, the organization of our brains. To suggest ways of reconciling the software of the mind with the hardware of the brain is a main goal of this book.

14. Page 309 In coming Chapters, where we discuss the brain, we shall examine whether the brain’s top level-the mind-can be understood without understanding the lower levels on which it both depends and does not depend. Are there laws of thinking which are “sealed off” from the lower laws that govern the microscopic activity in the cells of the brain? Can mind be “skimmed” off of the brain and transplanted into other systems? Or is it possible to unravel thinking processes into neat and modular subsystems? Is the brain more like an atom, a renormalized electron, a nucleus, a neutron, or a quirk? Is consciousness an epiphenomenon? To understand the mind, must one go all the way down to the level of the nerve cells?

15. Page 322 I find it much easier to change points of view. When I do so, vocabulary of technology comes back: the MEANING of the caste distribution and PURPOSFULNESS of signals. This not only happens when I think of aunt colonies, but also when I think about my own brain and other brains. However, with some effort I can always remember the other point of view if necessary, and drain all these systems of meaning too.

16. Page 349 on Modules Which Mediate Thought Processes: Philosophically, the most important question of all this: What would the existence of modules-for instance, a grandmother module-tell us? Would this give us any insight into the phenomenon of our own consciousness? Or would it still leave us as much in the dark about what consciousness is, an does knowledge that a brain is built out of neurons and glia? The crucial step that needs to be taken is from a low-level – neuron to neuron – description of the same state of brain. ….we want to shift the description of the brain state from signal level to symbol level.
a. My thought; I am not sold on this as I get from the same material that intelligence is a construct of colliding ideas at the messenger level-the RNA level, not the DNA symbol level.

17. Page 349 It is an interesting question whether in each symbol there are certain core neurons, which invariably fire when the symbol is activated. If such a core set of neurons exists, we might refer to it as the “invariant core” of the symbol.

18. Page 355 Sometimes conditions can arise where two previously unlinked symbols get activated simultaneously and in a coordinated fashion. The may fit together so well that it seems like an inevitable union. And a single new symbol is formed by the tight interaction of the two old symbols. If this happens, it would be fair to say that the new symbol “always had been there but never had been activated” – or should one say it has been “created”?

19. Page 360 Our facility for making instances out of classes and classes out of instances lies at the basis of our intelligence, and it is one of the great differences between human thought and the thought processes of other animals.

20. Page 378 reliable pathways of (thought or reason) are what constitute knowledge. Pieces of knowledge merge gradually with beliefs, which are also represented by reliable pathways, but perhaps ones which are more unsusceptible to replacement if, so to speak, a bridge goes out, or there is a heavy fog. This leaves us with fancies, lies, falsities…

21. Page 381 You will again chunk these programs in your mind, looking for conceptual hardware, you are not comparing software-you are comparing “etherware” the pure concepts which lie back of the software. There is some sort of abstract “conceptual skeleton” which must be lifted out of the low levels before you can carry out a meaningful comparison of two programs in different computer languages, of two animals, or of sentences in different natural languages.

22. Page 383 The physical status of a brain, if read correctly, gives information telling not which pathways could be followed, but rather how much resistance could be offered along the way.

23. Page 385 To be precise, by “subsystem”, I mean a constellation of symbols, each of which can be separately activated under the control of the subsystem itself. The image I wish to convey of a subsystem is that it functions almost as an independent “subbrain”, equipped with its own repertoire of symbols which can trigger each other internally.

24. Page 389 Although conscious beings have the power of going on, we do not wish to exhibit this simply as a succession of tasks they are able to perform, nor do we see the mind as an infinite sequence of selves and super-selves. Rather, we insist that a conscious being is a unity, and though we talk about parts of the mind, we do so only as a metaphor, and will not allow it to be taken literally.

25. Page 407 the pq system does not include enough of the core truths of N to count as “a number theory.” What, then, are these core truths of N? They are the primitive recursive truths: that means the involve only predictably terminating calculations.

26. Page 429 If we accept CT-Thesis, we have to conclude that Gloop is a myth – there are no restrictions to remove in Floop, no ways to increase its power by unshackling it as we did ion Bloop.

This puts us in the uncomfortable position of asserting people can calculate Reddiag [N] for any value of N, but there is no way to program a computer to do so. For if it could be done at all, it could be done in Floop – and by construction, it can’t be done in Floop. This conclusion is so peculiar that it should cause us to investigate very carefully the pillars on which it rests. And one of them if you will recall, was our shaky assumption that there is a decision procedure which can tell terminating form non terminating Floop programs. The idea of such a decision procedure already seemed suspect, when we saw the existence would allow all programs of number theory to be solved in a uniform way. Now we have double the reason for believing that any termination test is a myth – that there is no way to put Floop programs in a centrifuge and separate out terminators from non terminators.

27. Page 438 The first key idea of Godel’s proof is the deep discovery that there are strings of TNT which can be interpreted as speaking about other strings of TNT; in short, that TNT as a language, is capable of “introspection”, or self scrutiny. This is what comes from Godel-numbering. The second key idea is that the property of self scrutiny can be entirely concentrated into a single string; thus that string’s sole focus of attention is itself. This “focusing trick” is traceable, in essence, to Cantors diagonal method.

28. Page 479 In Zen too, we can see this preoccupation with the concept of transcending the system.

29. Page 501 But recall that in Chapter VI, we made the concept of “intrinsic meaning” dependent on a hypothesized universal notion of intelligence. The idea was that, in determining the intrinsic meaning of an object, we could disregard some types of outer message – those which would be universally understood. That is, if the decoding mechanism seems fundamental enough, in some ill-defined sense, then the inner message which it lets be revealed is the only meaning that counts.

30. Page 503 Clearly an individual is never identical to either of its parents: why, then, is the act of making young called “self reproduction”? The answer is that there is a course grained isomorphism between parent and child; it is an isomorphism which preservers information about species, Thus what is reproduced is the class, rather than the instance.

31. Page 517 As was mentioned above, in many cells, DNA, the ruler of the cell, dwells in its private “Throne Room” the nucleus of the cell. But most of the “living” in the cell goes on outside of the nucleus, namely the cytoplasm – the “ground” to the nucleus “figure” In particular, enzymes which make practically every life process go, are manufactured by ribosome in the cytoplasm, and they do most of their work in the cytoplasm.

32. Page 519 Now when a strand of mRNA, after it escapes into the cytoplasm, encounters a ribosome, a very intricate and beautiful process called translation takes place. It could be said that this process of translation is at the very heart pf all life, and there are many mysteries connected with it.. But essence it is easy to describe. First let us give a picturesque image, and then render it more precise. Imagine the mRNA to be like a long piece of magnetic recording tape, and the ribosome to be like the tape recorder. As the tape pass through the playing head of the recorder, it is “read” and converted into music, or other sounds. Thus magnetic markings are “translated” into notes. Similarly,, when a “tape” of mRNA passes through the “playing head” of a ribosome, the “notes” which are produced are amino acids, and the “pieces of music” which they make up are proteins. This is what translation is all about.

33. Page 541 Henkin Sentences and Viruses: Now both of these contrasting types of self-reference in molecular biology have their counter parts in mathematical logic. We have already discussed the analogue of self-defeating phages – namely, strings of the Godal type, which assert their its own unproducibility within specific formal systems. But one can also make a counterpart sentence to a real phage: the phage asserts its own producibility in a specific formal system. Sentences of this type are called Henkin Sentences, after the mathematical logician Leon Henkin. They can be constructed exactly along lines of Godal sentences, the only difference being the omission of a negation. One begins with an “uncle” pf course: 3a3a’:

34. Page 547 Illustrative of this is the amazing fact that in biological systems,all the various features necessary for self replication (viz language, program, data, interpreter and processor) cooperate to such a degree that all of them are replicated simultaneously – which show how much deeper is biological self-rep’ing than anything else yet devised along those lines by humans.

35. Page 559 We have come to the point where we can develop one of the main theses of this book: that every aspect of thinking can be viewed as a high-level description of a system which, on a low level, is governed by simple, even formal rules. The system is of course is the brain – unless one is speaking of thought processes flowing in another medium, such as computer circuits.

36. Page 577 There is no reason to believe that a computer’s faultlessly functioning hardware could not support high-level symbolic behavior which would represent such complex states as confusion, forgetting, or appreciation of beauty. It would require that there be massive subsystems interacting with each other according to a complex logic. The overt behavior could appear either rational or irrational, but underneath it would be the performance of reliable, logical hardware.

37. Page 582 by contrast, the semantic aspects of form are those which cannot be tested in predictable lengths of time: the require open ended test. Such an aspect is theoremhood of TNT-strings, as we have seen. You cannot just apply some standard test to a string and find out it is a theorem. The act of pulling out a string’s meaning involves, in essence, establishing all the implications of its connections to all other strings, and this leads, to be sure, down open-ended trail. So semantic properties are connected to open ended searches because an object’s meaning is not localized within the object itself. This is not to say that no understanding of any object’s meaning is possible until the end of time, for as time passes, more and more of the meaning unfolds. However there are always aspects of its meaning which will remain hidden arbitrarily long.

38. Page 618 Representing Knowledge In a Logical Formalism: The basic operations in such representations are, not surprisingly, formalizations of deductive reasoning. Logical deductions can be made using rules of inference analogous to some of those in TNT. Querying the system about some particular idea sets up a goal in the form of a string to be derived.