Showing posts with label virtue. Show all posts
Showing posts with label virtue. Show all posts

Sunday, October 27, 2013

Madame Bovary


By Gustave Flaubert

I picked this book up at a used bookstore in Traverse City a couple of years ago. I picked it up largely because it is an old French classic of original copyright printing & binding, simply to add to my bookshelf. I pulled it off my bookshelf to possibly discover in a classic, a lifestyle that may provide clues as to where or at what time in history man began his deference of self-accountability to his government. The book in modern times in a mid American crowd would be an Oprah chic book. So I was struck to find myself reading it. I had no clue of what I was getting in to. As it is a drama about the life of Madame Bovary, which could happen to anyone. The real beauty in the book is the French description, and the thought-provoking message. Character and setting introduction goes as follows.

The setting of the story is in the farm country of Western France. You could imagine slightly rolling hills carved by the intersection of two rivers, cultivated and rich in crop. The small towns are situated about fifteen miles from each other and each with a population of a hundred to two. The Bovary’s lived in town and from their house you get the impression that they could tune in to all that is happening by putting ones head out the window. The Bovary house came with one servant and was your typical middle-income house with a piano that may have had them in slight advantage over others. All in all it was a setting for a pretty quiet and uneventful life. The key characters help define the authors message.

Charles Bovary - was molded by his mothers drive. She set his life’s charter to be a doctor. His first effort was a failure due to the decision not being his own. However his second effort on the boot of his father proves successful. As he grew into his practice and got fat as his focused was on both his patients and his wife. He was well respected; a loving and caring husband, yet not refined to the manners of Paris. He fell into life.

Madame Bovary’s - (Emma) moral fabric was weaved in a convent. There she learned the morals of life’s decisions She came to appreciate art, music, and culture was well read. When her mother died she returned to the farm to help her father out. It was in this setting that she met Monsieur Bouvary, succumbed to a courtship out of limited choice and marriage partially arranged, partially promoted by her father. She battled through life.

Leon – a bit younger than Emma is a dreamer and also longing for the city. His longing for academic study and for culture led to his departure to Paris to pursue a career in law.

Rodolphe - was bachelor, a lady’s man. He was rich and developed selfish designs on Emma that go too far for a confirmed bachelor. He realizes her longing for arts and culture and plays into them only to have a mistress shackled in a marriage where he may have his way with her and also live his life of solitude.

Lormeaux - is the local merchant. I am always intrigued of the venue for distribution of goods of that time as well the understanding and practice of commercial exchange. Lormeaux extends credit to Emma and therefore plays the role of merchant and capitalist. This represents store credit cards of today. The main business difference is simple interest -v- compounding interest. Secondarily is today’s stores are much better situated to absorb losses for those that default on their loans. The personal interaction is less noticeable where one is not aware of the obligation to repay and consequence upon society and our economy for not doing so. Through the character of Lormeaux: the signing of a promissory notes, the negotiation of debt among other businessmen, and the tendering of debt paper as payment is described as common place of the times. Today that process is made as transparent as possible and I find that the average person may only witness with the transfer of a mortgage. Thus a stranger collecting on a debt, changing the unwritten understandings of the primary lender, do not occur.

In summary the story line picks up where marriage for Emma was an awakening where she soon discovered that her passion for a finer life could not be met with Charles. She was a good wife and tended to the house with elegance, yet inside she was burning for something more. Monsieur Bouvary was invited to a country party where she danced with a Viscount. The dance illuminated her desires for city life. Depression from absence of arts set in so drastically that Charles moved his practice to a new town in Yoneville, hoping a change in setting would cure her ailment. Coincidently their first child came along and Emma’s preoccupation with motherhood temporarily masked her passions. She discovers in young Leon someone she can share in her passion for art and culture. The passion for each other is lit, however restraint, founded in a moral code, prevails. It was Emma’s attempt to put mind over passion. Leon would eventually leave Yoneville for a Paris leaving a tremendous vacuum in Emma’s life.

This sets the stage for Rodolphe. In the vacuum he sweeps in and cultivates four years of escapade and rendezvous. In classic French style of the time the scenes are romantic, not naughty. While Rodolphe plays the cock that couldn’t crow with a strut instead, Emma plans a life together. Rodolphe plays along only to continue this perfect bachelor arrangement. Emma incurs tremendous debt arranging an escape to a new life only to find Rodolphe leaves her in a lurch. The scene draws a contrast of morals.

A moral code: “but one must bow to the opinion of the world and accept it’s moral code”
But there are two types “The small conventional, that of men, that which constantly changes, that brays out so loudly, that makes such a commotion here below. Of earth and earthy. But the other, the eternal, that is about us and the blue heavens that give us light”

This contrast sets the stage for the return of Leon. While there is at first an attempt for restrain an affair is lit by a carriage ride of lovemaking. This time however this time Emma is in control. This time Leon plays the part of the mistress. Emma spins a web of lies, waiting to be unraveled. Love turns to everyday life of which Emma funds through revenue from Charles’s patients and an over extension of her ability to repay her debt. She implores Charles to extend a power of attorney to manage the money of the house. Imagine this power not being implied through a marriage license. After this book one would be compelled to revert back to the ways of old. As an indication to the evolution away from personal responsibility the book includes a dialogue between Lormeaux and Charles with Lormeaux saying, “A man of science should not be troubled with matters of money”. This gives Lormeaux, with full knowledge of Emma’s agenda by way of the things she purchases, free access to the pocket book of unsuspecting Charles.

As events of the economy changed, Emma’s debt fell upon the decision making of persons not privy to the nature of her debt. And as such strict adherence to repayment was rudely and with great surprise introduced to Madame Bovary. Without knowledge of the custom of repayment to a stranger collecting on a debt, Bovary never considered changing the unwritten understandings of the primary lender, which previously allowed her a never-ending continuance of debt. As her passion for culture eroded to a lust for things she could not fairly gain she was rendered incapable of good business judgment. In the face of a bankruptcy process whereby the town official comes in to your home and prices all belongings for auction to facilitate repayment her solution an act was to take her own life.

In closing Charles, only after an honorable funeral, discovers the years of love letters and the deception. This discovery leads to the mysterious passing of Charles, where you conclude he simply lost all meaning of life. This left their daughter Berthe who you are left wondering about. The two metaphors from this book that give meaning to me are: When words fall short in the expression of ones heart: “They like a cracked kettle, on which we hammer out tunes to make bears dance, when we long to move the stars” “A lifetime of passion can be fit in a minute”. These are only to think about, as I have not an answer. My preference for poetic expression is though renewed from words like these. For they ironically do paint a meaningful picture best left to poetic interpretation. I did find the answer to a much simpler question; which is how a person could loose sight of personal accountability, virtue.

Wednesday, May 15, 2013

Anna Karenina



Anna Karenina
By Leo Tolstoy

This book has been on my list for ever.  First because it’s Tolstoy.  Second it’s a ‘chick’ book, or so I thought.  But really, it was simply next on the list. However coincidentally, its theme has much in common with books I have read over the past year.  This book, along with East of Edin and Answer Like a Man all deal on some level with virtue; specifically a woman’s lack of it.  I read each of these books at random urges where coincidence of theme was unbeknownst to me as the books sat silently on their shelves.  Ironically and coincidentally, I personally endured the consequences of this trait in society.  While I have torn myself up over it over in the past year, I am somewhat mollified by the fact that from prolific authors; Leo Tolstoy, John Steinbeck, Taylor Caldwell, and to include Guatav Flaubert's  Madame Bovary, one finds that virtue and women do not automatically go hand in hand.  To make my point, society over a hundred year span of time has made each of these books best sellers of their day and classics of today.  Why? Is a woman’s virtue to be tested as in Anna Karenina?  A woman’s beauty teases men and vexes society of both men and women.  Is a flower only to be seen and not touched at will?  Love of animal nature has no choice.  Like bees to a flower men pursue.  Like a flower should a woman surrender to each one?  By whom and how is the choice for virtue made.  What is the rationale for or against virtue?  These are the questions that Tolstoy explores on a word, a symbol of reality, where the meaning’s are conflicted.

The book opens with an affair of Anna’s cousin.  For which Anna tells her husband that she is going to Moscow to advise her cousin to forgive her adulterous husband.  Anna’s husband’s first response is to question that adultery may be forgiven, especially by his wife.  Anna’s response is “do you think that nine years of marriage should count for nothing against an infatuation?”  His answer is “No, but sin has a price you may be sure of that.”  The book’s moral message is weaved through typical Tolstoy voluminous depth, including sub plots involving first Kitty and Constantine  and his brother who marries a whore.  Each sub plot helps the reader experience the cross-sections of each thread of a tapestry of sin.  Kitty at first turns down Constantine’s proposal for marriage but after observing Ann’s sins, along side Constantine’s bother’s honorable faux marriage; she changes her mind and becomes a virtuous wife.  Tolstoy leaves the reader to visualize a marriage of peasants held together by virtue.  It knows no gender as parties of all sides including the sidelines feel its tension. 

As the story goes:
Coincidentally enough; Anna rides the train to Moscow with the mother of her eventual adulterous lover who poses the question of gossip and love to Anna.  The mother says it always turns up that amidst the rumor she would always wish she had the affair, though she hadn’t.  She asks Anna her opinion and her response was “I don’t know.”  I am familiar with a mother capable of that statement. Are a mother’s sins  passed down to become sins of their sons and daughters?  Why does Tolstoy add this dynamic?  Well I suspect he is making a point that anyone can fall prey to society and infatuation, only to leave your life in ruins.  Upon leaving the train the arrogant son Bronski, son of the mother mentioned above who  is introduced to a Anna, a married woman and mother of a young son.  With this knowledge in hand he persists in yet immediate plots and assault on her virtue.  His methods are selfish, devious, and relentless.  I know a man capable of stooping to these bowels of character.


In this book Tolstoy deals with love at lust’s level.  At the height of orgasm Anna’s cries Oh “god forgive me, that’s the end of everything,   I have nothing left now but you.”  She cries murder, murder!  Alexi replies “I can only remember my happiness.”  For which Anna says, “You murdered my happiness.” All of her senses are lost.  Her soul is sold to the devil.   Love of the flesh is now managed by the heart alone.  Anna lives for her new lover’s happiness at the expense of all her family and most of all herself.  Her new found happiness is co-dependent on her lover.  Over time she realizes the ‘demons in her head’ in the form jealousy in her, but also knows it is too late for saving or redemption.

Tolstoy also balances this love with forgiveness, forgiveness in this case being a discipline of the mind/ego.  Anna falls prey to her passions, while being seduced by a gentleman and cavalry officer of society, Alexi Bronski.  It was new emotion in an otherwise very settled bourgeois life.  She was being pursued; it was refreshing compared to the life she was leading, albeit a very comfortable life as the wife of a minister of the Russian royal court.  While she was pleading for the fulfillment of her loins with Alexi her lover, she comes to realize her mistake on her apparent death bed. After baring Alexi’s child she asks her husband to forgive the both of them. 

In the course of her husbands struggle with this dichotomy of nerve and passion, Tolstoy plays out societies impressions.  In the drama, society is also vexed.  They sit at parties and consensus would hold that love, of Anna’s nature, is to die for.  It would be living and dying for your highest desire, be it right or wrong.  I believe it would be Voltaire who would say see!!!  And then at the same time that same society scorns Anna in her attempt to bring this new love into society without even concluding her divorce with her current husband.  I have experienced this in a woman who brings to life perpetual attacks of this disease.   The lesson of coincidence you would ask, I had no idea this was the plot or the plots of the previously mentioned books had parallel trends.  This book ends with Anna’s demise under the wheels of a train and her husband sitting comfortably with Anna’s children in a field reading a book.  In all books the virtuous live to see their virtue.  But for mankind the drama continues insanely.

Apparently betraying virtue haunts the soul; the aspect of man that lives through eternity.   Betrayal of virtue brings along an accomplice; jealousy.   Anna began to realize two things.  First she recognized the demons in her head during her jealous moments with Alexi.  She realized that she had nothing materially to be jealous for and that her jealousy was self born.  She also began to realize that her own adultery may have inflicted her jealousy on her lover. She asked him for forgiveness.  Anna was capable of asking for forgiveness and love but incapable of returning anything but animal lust.  Having received love, the unconditional acceptance of her being, from not one but two men outwardly, the conflicted Anna Karenina, at the peak of emotional despair threw herself under a moving train. 

So what is Tolsky trying to tell us?  I suspect he is saying that the conscience of society and the true nature of the animal in man are at odds with each other.  Conscience of man, that which makes us beings above animals has the luxury of choice.  Spirit of man is the fabric of society that scorns animal lust.  Spirit of society embraces a man and a woman in marriage if for no other reason than to spawn raise children, which in fact is the survival of our species.  Anna Karenina violated that virtuous quality in humans and her conscience as a consequence would not let her survive.  To Anna’s credit at least she had a conscience.  Victor Hugo’s Madam Bovary with her many lovers does not.  Mirror mirror in the sky what is love?



Virtue

A virtuous woman guards against seduction
Preoccupied with the beauty of innocence
To prowling libidos of wolves, devil’s temptation
She’s content to alluring dance yet portrays reluctance
Consumed by footsteps of over bearing passion
The lamb loses her footing to wolves’ persistence

Succumbed not to his demands but a hidden hand
Past the heat of passion it was hers to control
Once virtue surrenders, ego’s devises take command
The devil’s gimmicks are released and let out on parole
Conscience registers his vote to heart’s upper hand
To unconsciousness only her humor can she cajole


Is it the carnivorous nature of wolves and lambs?
Or is it the waltz of bee over the fragrant flower?
Lambs will bleat a beaeah an invitation to the wolf
The roosters will strut beneath the circling hawk
Is it moral excellence to give and take of love…making?
Can its courage see through the conflicted meaning?