Sunday, December 2, 2007

Farewell to Arms

Farewell to Arms
by Ernest Hemingway

A "classic" book, by a classic author? For me, after this read the question remains at large. This book is mostly a life/love story about a foreign national couple who found each other while managing their lives on the Italian side of the Austro/Italian front of the Great War. I call it the Great War because in Hemmingway style, the book is written so much in absolute first person that construction of the main character, Henry, does not make the date setting clear until the last part of the book. Hemmingway does indeed live up to his reputation for making you feel "right there" inside the body” of the main characters.

He builds an appreciation for the moral conscience of those engaged in war. He describes the people within his medical unit as ambivalent to the power mongers of the commanders on either side of the armies at war. This observation does indeed resonate with other material I've read, whereby even the magistrates of the countries involved, were disconnected and somewhat not in control of their armies.

The other moral message that Hemingway raises is one whereby life keeps beating a person into submission of the throws of society. He raises this in the conclusion of the book where Henry looses both his wife and newborn first son in childbirth. Both moral lessons are merely broached with little story line follow through.

The book is only 300 pages in length, which leads me to conclude that his moral lessons were mere coincidences in the course of telling a love story. I can say that his reputation had me looking for a deeper pool of thought. To his credit, he did a nice job describing the northern Italian and Swiss countryside. I can say I did find myself envious of the lifestyle of the average American man with a wealthy father of 1916 in Europe. Send me more money!!!

2 comments:

ndad47 said...

I think Hemingway is lauded for this book because it is one of the first books that looks at war realistically. He doesn't preach or become too metaphoric. war is meaningful and meaningless at the same time.

Paul Murphy said...

Ndad47...to your comment, that he was, lauded for work I hold in question. His book was just that; somewhat colerful but meaningless to me at the same time. I was looking for something to laud, but somehow missed it. How did I miss it? Was there anything to miss?

Can you give me any words to encourage me to take another look at Hemingway.

Also, War and Peace preceeded this work and was looked at war realistically, in mu opinion. I have a review on that as well. Your thoughts on that would be appreciated as well.

Thanks for your particpation.